Restaurants lasting almost eight decades in New York City is a rarity.Yet Doanue's managed just that until recently. This classic Manhattan eater y is shutting it's kitchen and closing it's dining room. Despite this , it gave thousands upon thousands of New Yorkers and tourists great food and drink.
Regular contributor and the paper's restaurant critic Pete Wells, wrote about this sad occurrence in yesterday's New York Times Wednesday Food section. The eatery started in 1950 when Irirsh immigrant Martin Donahue born in Country Galway built four restaurants for each of his four sons. Only one, run by his son Martin until he died in 2000, and now his granddaughter Maureen Donahue-Peters. ran it.However the city was not as it once was. it has become too crowded and noisy and Ms. Donahue -Peters would rather be at her second home in Westhampton. Still he has kept all the charming touches that were with the eatery during it;s first year. There is still the original early 1950's phone on the wall along with the checkerboard floor and blue glass engraving behind the bar of an elephant looming over a cocktail as if it were a mouse. Orders are still written up by hand. There is nothing electronic like what modern restaurants have. Even the menu is pure Americana. Yes there is steak and filet mignon but there is also Maryland turkey and gravy along with BOston scrod and Hawaiian ham steal.Hot turkey and roast beef sandwiches were also popular,.
Seventy-five years brought the famed and the regular tooIt was the hangout of such famed CBS journalists Walter Cronkite and Dan Rather as well as NBC's Matt Lauer . Former mayor Michael Bloomburg often dined at Donahue's as did Cardinal Timothy DOlan.Supreme Court Justice Anthony M. Kennedy was a regular in the old fashioned black vinyl booths. It even brought in such famous writers as the famed Tennessee Williams and Gay Talese. Even the infamous con man Bernie Madoff spent a few meals there. Yet it was also a neighborhood place. Diners like Brooke Emmerich has been coming to the eatery since childhood. She and her family lived around the corner and ate there every Thursday always enjoying Donahue; famed corned beef and cabbage.It never took long for non famous regulars t be treated like stars.Bartenders and servers knew their drink and meal preferences down pat.Unfortunately Donahi=ue'sw ontl be picked up by a new owner. Another type of restaurant will probably be moving in and with it a raise in rent. Not to worry though, Ms. Donahue=Peter has opened up a Donahues in Westhampton.The menu is more or less the same. There are chicken pot pies and steak dinners but also trendy salads to fit the diets of the posh East End/
Every good thing must come to an end. Sadly this is the case with Donahue's. It will live on in history and people's beloved memories of the place.